Crossen Engineering headquarters signage on building exterior, representing precision engineering and manufacturing expertise.

Deciding Whether Deep Drawing or Metal Spinning Suits Your Part

Cups, cans, housings, domes and enclosures can often be formed in more than one way. When a design calls for a hollow metal part from flat sheet, the choice usually narrows to two processes: deep drawing on a press, or spinning on a lathe. Both start with a flat blank, and both produce seamless parts, so the drawings alone rarely settle it.

The right answer depends less on the part itself and more on how many you need, what shape they are, and what the part has to do once it is made. This article explains how each process works, when each is the stronger option, and the questions worth asking before committing to tooling.

How deep drawing works

In deep drawing, a flat blank is held in place by a blank holder while a punch pushes it into a die cavity. The metal flows inwards and down around the punch to form a cup or shell. Deeper parts are produced in stages, with each redraw taking the part closer to its final depth and diameter without overstressing the material.

Because the punch and die define the shape, every part that comes off the tool follows the same geometry. Once the tooling is proven, cycle times are short, and the process runs consistently over long batches. At Crossen Engineering, deep drawn pressing runs on hydraulic and mechanical presses from 35 to 630 tonnes, across material thicknesses from 0.15 mm copper to 8 mm steel and stainless steel.

How metal spinning works

Spinning clamps a flat blank against a shaped mandrel, which rotates on a lathe. A roller tool then presses the metal progressively over the mandrel until it takes the mandrel’s shape. The process can be manual, relying on the spinner’s skill, or CNC-controlled for more consistent results.

Tooling is limited to the mandrel and rollers, so it is quicker and cheaper to produce than a matched press tool. The trade-off is that each part takes longer to form, and the process produces only shapes symmetrical around a central axis.

Where the two processes differ

Tooling cost and lead time. Deep drawing needs a matched punch and die, and complex parts may need several draw stages. That is a larger upfront investment than a spinning mandrel. Spinning is often chosen for prototypes or first articles for exactly this reason.

Volume and unit cost. Once a press tool is made, deep drawing forms each part in a single press stroke per stage. Across thousands or hundreds of thousands of parts, that speed brings unit cost down well below what spinning can achieve. Spinning holds its cost advantage at low volumes, where tooling savings outweigh the longer cycle time.

Part shape. Spinning is restricted to round, axisymmetric forms such as cones, domes, cylinders and bells. Deep drawing can produce square and rectangular boxes, oval sections and irregular shapes, as well as round parts. If the design includes flats, corners or non-circular features, deep drawing is usually the only one of the two that can form them directly.

Repeatability and tolerance: On a press, the tool controls the geometry, so dimensions stay consistent from the first part to the last. CNC spinning has narrowed the gap, but handspinning can vary between parts and operators. For components that must fit assemblies or pass dimensional inspection batch after batch, a press tool delivers more consistent results.

Size: Spinning lathes can form very large diameters without the cost of a press large enough to match. Deep drawing is limited by press tonnage, bed size and stroke, although larger hydraulic presses extend that range considerably.

Wall thickness: Both processes thin the material to some degree. In deep drawing, thinning is predictable and can be managed through tool design, blank size and the number of draw stages. In spinning, thinning depends on the method and, in manual work, the operator.

A side-by-side summary

FeatureDeep drawingMetal spinning
ToolingMatched punch and die, higher upfront costSingle mandrel, lower cost and quicker to make
Economic volumeMedium to very high volumePrototypes, one-offs and low to medium volume
Part shapeRound, square, rectangular and irregular formsAxisymmetric (round) forms only
Cycle timeShort, with a consistent press strokeLonger per part
RepeatabilitySet by the tool, consistent part to partGood on CNC spinning, more variable by hand
SizeLimited by press bed and strokeSuits large diameters on suitable lathes

When deep drawing is the better choice

Deep drawing tends to be the stronger option when:

  • annual volumes run into the thousands or more, and unit cost matters
  • the part is square, rectangular or irregular rather than round
  • dimensions need to stay consistent across repeat batches
  • the part needs piercing, trimming or flanging that can be built into the press tooling
  • the programme has a long production life, so tooling cost is spread across many parts

These conditions are common in sectors such as automotive, electric vehicles, material handling and renewable energy, where formed housings, covers and enclosures are ordered in repeat batches.

When spinning makes sense

Spinning remains a practical route for one-off and prototype parts, very large round components, and low annual volumes where a press tool would be hard to justify. It is also used for design trials where the geometry is still changing, since altering a mandrel costs less than reworking a draw die.

A common pattern is to spin early prototypes and switch to deep drawing once the design is fixed and volumes rise. Planning for that switch early helps. A part designed with draw radii, draft and material flow in mind will move onto press tooling with fewer changes than one designed purely around spinning.

Questions to ask before choosing

Before committing to either process, it is worth working through a few points with your supplier:

  • What are the expected annual volumes, and over how many years?
  • Is the part fully round, or does it include flats, corners, or offset features?
  • Which dimensions are critical, and what tolerances do they need to hold?
  • What secondary work does the part need, such as trimming, machining or assembly?
  • Is the design fixed, or likely to change after early samples?

The answers often point clearly to one process. Where they do not, a design review can show whether small changes to radii, depth, or material would make deep drawing viable and reduce unit costs.

Deep drawn parts from design to delivery

Crossen Engineering has manufactured metal-formed and plastic-moulded components from Belfast for over 40 years, supplying customers across the UK and Ireland. Deep-drawn parts are produced with in-house design support and toolmaking, so tooling can be developed and adjusted without relying on outside toolrooms.

Once formed, parts can move straight on to 6-axis robotic laser trimming, multi-axis CNC machining, assembly, and on-site inspection, under an ISO 9001:2015 quality system. We use the same approach for aerospace components such as lip skins, formed on a 630-tonne hydraulic deep draw press. We also serve the defence and nuclear sectors.

If you are weighing up deep drawing for a new or existing part, our team can review drawings and advise on tooling, materials and volumes. Find out more about our metal pressings capability or contact us to discuss your project.

Back to News
AD35L Machines

Get a quote today

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.